|
This may come as a shock to you--or you may become ecstatic as
you think about it: Someday your business will be sold or transferred
and you will no longer own or control it.
Will your business be ready to sell when you are? Without a plan
in place for that ultimate transfer, you are just working a job
and missing the opportunity to create wealth for you and your family.
Think about it. Would you be running your business differently
if your exit plan were an IPO? Of course you would. Your business
may not have the story or numbers to go public, but the principle
is the same. You create substantially more wealth by planning your
exit strategy than by letting that ultimate transfer sneak up on
you.
Your exit strategy planning consists of two parts: The Exit Strategy
Plan and The Exit Strategy Process.
The Exit Strategy Plan, which I cover in this article, consists
of determining your selling trigger situation and the most likely
buyer category for your business. It also includes setting a program
to enhance your value to that buyer. The Exit Process, is what you
do once you decide to sell or some circumstance forces you to sell.
The Exit Strategy Plan
The sale of your company will be to a specific buying entity or
it will be through an initial public offering (IPO).
Should You Do an IPO? Public companies have significantly higher
valuations than private companies. This is primarily because of
the liquidity of public stock. Call your stockbroker and it is sold!
In selling a private company, call your intermediary and hope it
sells within a year. Shannon Pratt, founder of Willamette Management
Associates, one of the oldest and largest independent valuation
consultants, states in his recent book, Cost of Capital, that discounts
for lack of liquidity are often in the range of 10% to 50%.
To be successful in the IPO world, a company has to have a story
that captures the public investor's eye.
Some mundane companies have successful IPOs without the story,
but they have the financial performance (numbers) to support the
valuations. The threshold for a successful IPO is a market capitalization
(shares outstanding times market price per share) of at least $250,000,000.
Below that number the mutual funds and the market analysts are not
interested. As a result, the stock doesn't have the support to sustain
the value in the market.
The up front costs to go public are significant--in the $400,000
to $700,000 range. And it takes significant management time for
an extended period.
There are cheaper ways to go public such as merging with a shell
company or one of the short-cut methods allowed by the Security
and Exchange Commission. The key issue is market capitalization.
Using one of these methods for a small company lets you enjoy all
the negatives of being public without the benefits.
I am personally familiar with several companies that took the shortcut
to going public. One went out at $5.00 three years ago and is now
trading at $0.15, and the business is essentially the same from
a profitability standpoint as it was three years ago. Big mistake--too
low market capitalization and no analysts' support. Now, the company
is a candidate to go private. It should have been private all along.
If all of the time, effort and money that went into going public
and sustaining the IPO had gone into growing the business, the company
would be much more valuable than it is now.
Recommendation: If your company has the potential market capitalization
of $250,000,000 and you have the stomach for the fishbowl of the
public arena, go public. If not, plan a private sale.
Buyers for private companies
There are two types of buyers: financial and synergistic (sometimes
called strategic). Financial buyers are interested in return on
investment (ROI). Synergistic buyers bring efficiencies resulting
from the combining of the buyer and seller thus enhancing the return
and making the combined entity more valuable than the sum of the
individual values. (2+2=5).
Ideally you could expect to receive a higher price from a synergistic
buyer. However the synergistic buyer will not offer a higher price
unless forced to do so. Forcing requires an auction environment
where two or more synergistic buyers bid against one another.
Categories of buyers
Let's consider the characteristics of various categories of buyers.
Unless it's an IPO or a involuntary transfer (see below) the ultimate
sale of your business will be to one of these.
Private Equity Groups (PEG)
Not a day passes that I don't get an inquiry from a private investment
group. There are over a thousand of these groups operating in the
country at the present time. These are groups of financial buyers
who have raised capital from pension funds, banks, foundations and
high net worth individuals with the purpose of investing in and
owning middle market companies (usually $5 to $100 million in annual
revenues).
While the specific acquisition criteria vary from PEG to PEG, any
middle market company is of interest to most of these groups. Their
purchase can take many different formats. One format is straight
sale, with selling principals participating in equity and management
Management buyout (PEG funds inside management buyout) Management
buyout of a division Management buy-in (PEG funds outside management
buyout) Industry consolidation and roll-up (PEG backs management
to buy other companies)
Typically PEGs are financial buyers, however some of the older
PEGs have other companies in their portfolios that present a synergistic
situation.
Individual buyers
These are high net worth individuals. Some are previous owners of
businesses who are looking to get back into business.
Many are former corporate executives who have been downsized or
ostracized from their big corporation and are out there looking
to buy a business. My experience is that most of these people never
buy a business. They spend a year or two looking, the money runs
out or they get burned out on looking.
Going from a plush corporate job to running a small business is
culture shock. As you well know, sometimes one has to sweep the
floor or even get his/her own coffee!
One of my clients had an insightful remark about his metal bending
business. He said, "If an individual buyer had enough money to afford
my business, he or she wouldn't want it."
Also, there are lots of individual wannabes out there with no money
who want you to finance the deal for them. Make sure you fully qualify
potential suitors both technically and financially before spending
time with them. I often tell these people, "You can buy a business
with no money, but you can't buy a business with no money if you
have no money." Many times they will put you off with "My uncle
(or some other individual) is going to help with the financing."
If so, talk with the uncle who can make the investment decision.
Family members
About 30% of the country's family businesses are passed on to the
second generation and only 15% make it to the third generation says
Nancy Drodow, project manager for the Family Business Program at
Wharton School of Business. If you have a son, daughter or other
family member that is capable of taking over the business, consider
yourself very lucky (or very talented in training and motivating
them to do so).
Payment for the company is an issue with family members. Many times
the succeeding generation doesn't have the money to fund the transaction.
And if the seller takes paper, what happens if payments don't come.
Do you sue or foreclose on your daughter?
Of course, this is moot if you give the business to your daughter.
If you choose this, remember gift taxes and plan to minimize them.
Theory of relativity in business: "What good is a business if it
can't take care of a few relatives?"
Competitors
Competitors may feign interest just to learn how to better compete
with you. Tread carefully. Some competitors would love to tell your
customers that you are selling.
Competitors have the dilemma of deciding whether to pay you for
your goodwill and equipment versus foregoing buying you and spending
the money on marketing to convert your customers.
For the most part, competitors don't make good buyer candidates.
Having said that, a company in the same business in a different
geographic market or with a complementary product line may be the
ideal buyer in that they can bring significant synergy to the deal.
Customers
Many times your business will be of interest to customers who
are looking to vertically integrate. The issue the customer has
is will the other customers of the business remain after the transaction
since they now see their supplier as a competitor.
Seldom are customers buyers.
Suppliers
Suppliers have the same issues as customers in that customers visualize
them as competitors after the close.
The vertical integration strategy is out of vogue with the current
trend to outsourcing.
Employees
Frequently a partner employee will buy out another partner. It's
rare that a pure employee has the funds and/or the collateral to
buy the business. I have seen successful management buyouts with
the help of PEGs.
When you sell to an employee with a low down payment, you still
own the business because you have to worry about payments and worry
about getting the business back.
ESOP (Employee Stock Ownership Plan)
An ESOP is a government-approved program that allows the employees
to buy the business. This is a program where the owner sells stock
to a trust that has the employees as beneficiaries. The trust is
funded by pretax contributions by the company based on a percentage
of the payroll. The payroll has to be large enough in relation to
the value of the business to make sense.
ESOPs work in cases where there is competent successor management
in place or where the owner is willing to stay around and run the
business until management can be in place.
The qualifications to establish an ESOP are highly technical, so
make sure you have an ESOP consultant to lead you though the process
of establishing and managing the trust.
With an ESOP, the employees buy stock in the company with pretax
dollars and, in addition, the seller can defer income taxes on the
gain.
Venture capital and angel investors
One could interpret raising money through venture capital or through
angel investors as selling part of the company. As far as this discussion
goes, I consider that as a part of the process to ultimately go
public. If you are raising money in that manner, you are on the
path to going public and all of the IPO qualifications and comments
above apply.
Involuntary transfer
Part of the exit planning process is thinking about potential
involuntary scenarios in your business and taking steps to reduce
to potential of those scenarios happening. Early planning will substantially
reduce the likelihood of an involuntary sale.
In my experience, the four most likely involuntary events are:
Owner's health, Bankruptcy, Government intervention and Natural
catastrophe
Owner health
The objective of every business owner should be to create a business
with second tier management capable of running the business without
the participation of the owner. A business with this characteristic
is of maximum value to any buyer because the buyer's risk of transfer
is substantially reduced. And a business with this characteristic
can survive serious owner health events.
It goes without saying that you should have a trained replacement
for your job. Every job in the organization should have a replacement
trained and cross-trained. All of the systems and procedures of
the organization should be documented.
One of the great benefits of ISO 2000 certification is documentation
of systems and procedures such that replacement training becomes
easier thus reducing the risk of sudden owner health or other personnel
changes jeopardizing the viability of the business.
Bankruptcy
Bankruptcies happen when a business has a cash crunch or a threat
of a cash crunch. Some of the situations I've seen leading to bankruptcy
include: loss of major lawsuit, under capitalization, bet-the-business
decision that doesn't work out, embezzlement, product obsolescence,
key employee becoming competitor, severe economic downturn in industry
and bankruptcy of customer. I have seen companies forced into bankruptcy
because they grew too fast and ran out of cash. You probably know
of many other situations.
Some of these situations are beyond the control of the owner. The
advice I give is to assess the risks in your business and take steps
to reduce them. Make a list and evaluate the likelihood and severity
of each risk item. For example, should the volume of business you
do with one customer suddenly cease with that customer owing you
money, would your business survive?
There is no such thing as a risk-free business, but assessing the
risks and planning to handle them can substantially reduce likelihood
of bankruptcy.
Bankruptcy is an expensive, debilitating experience. It bleeds
the business owner, sometimes even more than the event that caused
the bankruptcy in the first place. Bankruptcies should be avoided
at all costs except in those rare occasions where the motivation
is a strategic negotiating ploy.
If you are threatened with bankruptcy, first think of working with
a Credit Managers' Association. Many areas have these associations
that act in a non-judicial way to help you through your period of
trouble. The credit managers realize that surviving a bankruptcy
is difficult at best and their members will likely receive more
return from their claims outside of bankruptcy than inside it.
Government intervention
As the dramatic picture of the Government taking young Elian Gonzales
at gunpoint shows, the Government can do anything it wants to-it
has the guns and power to ruin your business. You need to manage
any situation relative to the government's regulations and taxation
and issues on politicians' current politically incorrect list.
Natural catastrophe
Are you in an area subject to earthquakes, floods? Could the business
survive a fire? Are your records secured? My advice is to have a
disaster plan. Making time for disaster recovery planning is never
easy. There is no good time-just don't wait until after the disaster
happens.
Deciding to sell
What will the triggering event be prompting your decision to sell?
Will it be when the value of the business exceeds the financial
goals you have for retirement? Will it be when you reach 65 or some
other pre-determined age? Will it be when all the kids leave home
or get out of college? Is it dependent upon some event in your industry?
Will it be when you need to invest another $1 million to remain
competitive and you don't want the risk? Could it be burnout? Could
it be some passion you have to be a missionary in Azerbaijan? Or
do you just want to SCUBA dive in Belize for the rest of your days?
Think about what you want to do that Monday after it sells.
Some business owners never plan to retire; that is OK. Just make
sure there is a succession plan in place because we all are mortal.
Think about these scenarios and others and determine the most likely
event, then pick the most likely buyer category and plan your strategy
to enhance the value to that buyer.
And remember the typical length of time to sell a business is nine
to twelve months.
Answer these questions:
1. Are you an IPO candidate?
2. Are there family members you would like to have take over the
business?
3. Other than IPO or family member, who is the likely buyer or what
is the likely buyer category?
4. Do you have a replacement trained?
5. What will likely trigger your decision to sell?
6. What is your forecast for the timing of that decision?
7. What value do you need the company to be when you sell?
Next meet with your staff and create the company's strategic plan,
consistent with your exit plan. You don't have to share your exit
plan with your staff; you just have to guide the strategic planning
process so it is consistent with your exit plan.
Preparing a strategic plan forces you and your staff to take an
objective look at the business. The strategic plan document communicates
the strategy and the essence of the business to yourself and others.
It documents the future and can be very useful in communicating
the value generating character (and thus the value) of the business
to a buyer.
|